Testimonials

Patricia S.

I highly highly highly recommend Antonella’s for exceptional food and service. I’ve known Antonella for many years and loved her former restaurant, Belle Paese. The food was always perfection and so delicious. I was thrilled when she opened her catering business. She catered a recent holiday get-together we had with our friends and just like her restaurant, everything was absolutely delicious. From the fabulous meatball appetizer, to the rich and mushroom laden vegetable lasagna, to the special panna cotta and cannolis, our guests ate every last bit up, and raved about how delicious it was. Wonderful and creative food, and made with the very best ingredients, you can tell. Beautiful website and a great, straightforward menu and reasonable pricing. Antonella is delightful to work with and has so many good suggestions. I cannot praise her, her beautiful food, and her service enough. Everything is a 10++++++! I can’t wait to work with her again.

Ryan L.

We used Antonina for a dinner party. Her communication was fabulous and she always got back to us in a timely manner. The food was delicious and all of our guests loved it. We had plenty of leftovers and looking forward to eating them. We would definitely recommend her business, and would use her again. Thank you so much Antonina!

Rich B.

I would like to thank Antonella for catering our event, and helping us choose the menu. The food was great and everything was right on time.

Ken M.

We just had a family birthday party catered by Antonella. We gave her fairly short notice and she was very gracious to accommodate. The food was awesome and delicious and was the hit of the party. Would highly recommend for any of your catering needs!

Caroline B.

Food & service was INCREDIBLE!!! Antonella was so sweet and helpful when we were deciding what to get. Seriously nothing was bad – everything I ate was delicious. My entire family was raving over the food and we were fighting over the leftovers! I wish I remembered to take pictures of everything but we were all too excited to eat. Highly highly recommend using Antonella for any catering needs. 🙂

Charles K.

Cinque stelle! (5 stars). Cibo buonissimo! Molto saporito! Antonella is the greatest chef in Central Pennsylvania! We had a special occasion for which we wanted something unique and delicious. We got both. Planning and working with Antonella before the event was a true pleasure. She advised me on all aspects of the meal, including the cost which came out precisely. From start to finish, everything was tremendous – quality, freshness, quantity, taste, delivery, timeliness. All serving trays and warmers were set up beforehand and removed after the event ended. Absolutely every one of the guests raved about the food. We ordered a mix of separate pasta dishes, meatballs, mixed salad, special caprese pesto appetizers, and desserts of mini tiramisù and cannoli. The overwhelming favorite was the vegetable lasagne with béchamel sauce – Wow! Delizioso…molto delizioso! It was truly impressive how Antonella could provide so much food for so many people and it all tasted like it was made individually for each person. You get very high quality. I highly recommend using Antonella Modern Italian Fare for your special occasion!

Brenna V.

We had Antonella cater our wedding, and it was perfect! Everyone at our party raved about the food and the service. We would highly recommend Antonella’s catering for anyone’s special day!

Laura T.

Antonella recently catered our family holiday party. We had such a great experience working with her and would highly recommend her to our friends and family. The food was exceptional – we ordered a lot of food and have not one complaint about a single dish. Antonella was always available and flexible with timing for delivery, etc. We loved her restaurant in East York years ago. We are so happy to have found her new catering business and fully intend to work with her again in the future. Thanks for making out family gathering such a success!

Tanya R.

Always fresh, always fabulous! Love your food!

Ingrid M.

We ordered some plates with Antonella for our wedding celebration. Lasagna, Ravioli with cheese filling and vodka cream sauce and the desserts: mini Cannoli and Tiramisu. Everything was perfect!!!! Beautiful and delicious. Our guests loved! It was the best dishes we’ve ever eaten. We couldn’t recommend more. And Antonella was so kind and thoughtful. We’ll order again for every single event! No doubt!

H K

Antonella created the most delicious food for my recent party! Everyone raved about how good it was! And the portion sizes were very generous. The cannolis were out of this world and got eaten so fast I didn’t even get a chance for a photo! I HIGHLY recommend her! She was flexible, answered all my questions and made having the party a breeze.

G K

Antonella provided the food for our event and it was perfect. Fresh ingredients, authentic Italian, delivered with care. Highly recommended.

Christine P.

Antonella made a delicious chicken piccata for my birthday party. It easily fed 13 people plus leftovers. It was a hit with everyone! We appreciate her authentic Italian cooking and the love she puts in it! I highly recommend calling her for your next party!

Gisele S.

I love Antonella’s delicious sauces, vegetable lasagna and the best of all the Tiramisu. They are all made fresh, with really good quality and makes my life so much easier.

Sarah R.

We had a tragic death in the family before Christmas and we needed food for a lot of people who were at my in-law’s house. Doing take out every just did not make sense and for a few nights I would just reach out to Antonella and she would create these massive and delicious meals for us, so we could eat a home cooked meal together with zero stress of having to cook. It was such a blessing and she was so willing to help us at a time of total sadness. Thank you so much for what you did for us!

Karen S.

I used Antonella for our company luncheon. Everyone loved the food. She was very professional delivered the order exactly when she said she would it was hot and the set up was terrific. Our order was Chicken Marsala and roasted potatoes and cheese ravioli some of the employees commented on the ravioli and said they tasted like their grandmom’s, they were AMAZING. We are looking forward to using her again and again.
I want to thank her for making me look good since I was in charge of finding the caterer.
PS: If I could give her 10 stars I would!

Erika N.

Antonella is AMAZING, everything we had on Christmas was absolutely delicious!!

Marina K.

I have known Antonella for more than 20 years. She used to be the owner of Bel Paese in York, PA. Recently, I had the pleasure of hosting a birthday party for a family member, and I was absolutely thrilled to discover that Antonella had started a new catering business. Being Italian myself, I have high expectations when it comes to food, and I was confident that Antonella would deliver delicious flavors that truly capture the essence of our culture’s joy in celebrating life and special occasions.

I reached out to Antonella with no doubt in my mind that the food would be exceptional. And indeed, she exceeded all expectations. From the antipasti to the entrees, desserts, and cake, everything she prepared was a resounding success. The guests at my party were incredibly impressed, with some even stating that it was better than the food served at certain weddings they had attended.

I want to express my heartfelt gratitude to Antonella for making everything so special and delicious. The celebration wouldn’t have been the same without her incredible culinary skills. Thank you Antonella for adding that extra touch of perfection to the event.

Dianne W.

Antonella is the best cook. A dear friend of ours had suggested she cook for me during a time when my home was under construction and cooking was not possible. She made me the most amazing delicious meals. Healthy and very delicious! Even with dietary restrictions, she made the most wonderful meals. It was a life saver and now that my kitchen is almost finished I’m still having her cook for me and my elderly mother. Antonella is simply amazing! 🌟

Patricia K.

The food was perfect everyone loved it! The desserts were divine!

Zoe H.

Fresh lemon herbs chicken leg and thighs. My family and I get 3 weekly meals. They are so juicy and flavorful and also very filling. Everything I’ve tried so far is amazing! Highly recommend to anyone looking for true Italian dishes

Austin D.

WOW! Is all I can say after trying the Ossobuco. The food was absolutely bursting with flavor and the veal was unbelievably tender. The mixed veggies in the dish were so tasty and refreshing. Cannot wait to try more. 5 stars undoubtedly!

Dayanara V.

The Pasta Bolognese with meat sauce was delicious! You can taste the freshness of the ingredients and it was baked perfectly! I also tried the Tiramisu which was absolutely delicious! It melts in your mouth instantly and the coffee flavor isn’t too overpowering 🤤

Tyler M.

Absolutely the best Italian food you fill find in or around York. Her Gnocchi four cheese is especially out of this world!